Mystic Rogue Irish pub and restaurant - Chicago, Illinois

Kevin R.

Good atmosphere & friendly staff. Great Irish food with the Shepard’s Pie being absolutely delicious. I’d have taken a photo of the Mashed Potato Ball appetizer, but I finished them before I thought to take a picture because of how great they were. TV has entertaining movies playing, if you go solo, & the drinks are poured like they hate their boss. Most definitely will be returning again.

Kenneth E.

The food is phenomenal service was excellent my server was nice friendly I brought a family member from Boston and I was taking her to the airport and decided to come in and have lunch best decision I ever made her next return trip to Chicago we're definitely going to come back and have lunch and dinner

Raylynn

On a recent Thursday evening, 4 of us went to Mystic Rogue Irish Pub for the first time. When the server took our drink order, I asked for a daiquiri. She returned from the bar and stated that the bartender could not make a daiquiri because they did not have a blender. I responded with "you do not need a blender to make a daiquiri." The server chose to not relay that information to the bartender, and instead suggested that I order something from their drink menu. I ordered a Mr. Gold, and requested that rum be substituted for the whiskey, and the club soda be omitted. After a long wait, the drink served to me was made with rum, simple syrup, and lime juice. That is a daiquiri. How is it possible to be a bartender and not know how to mix this simple well drink? The check came to $119, and we tipped $26. We will probably not return to Mystic Rogue. Ordering a drink should not have been that difficult.

G N.

We stopped here for lunch on the way to the city. The owner happened to be bartending and we had a great time- he was super friendly! We had the Ruben roles and Buffalo dip- both were awesome! We will be back for sure!

Bill L.

Great place, awesome atmosphere and light years better than the previous ownership/name that was in this location. Friendly & attentive staff even though they were packed. Great beers, good food and a lot of fun. I’ll be back for sure

Rita C.

I was visiting in Chicago & arranged to meet up with a friend there one day for brunch. We stayed chatting for hours & the atmosphere was great, staff excellent & food & drinks were also fabulous. I met with cousins another afternoon and i was not surprised that the excellent, food, service & atmosphere was fantastic.

Karolis K.

We are so happy to have this new Irish gem in the neighborhood. The food is great, had the Reuben, wings and Irish Stew all were fantastic, the stew might look better in a bowl though. The staff was welcoming and attentive, I believe we were served by Debbie. Keep up the great work and we can't wait to get back and try everything else on your menu.

Rafi A.

I found this place on Yelp when we wanted a festive restaurant. It did not disappoint. The waitress was sweet and attentive, the food about what you'd expect at an Irish pub, and the live Irish Gallagher singers made our cold Harp and Guinness draft beers go down that much smoother. It is a very warm atmosphere, a great place to spend time with friends.

So good, in fact, that I booked our party of 27 for the day after Thanksgiving here. The manager calls me four days before the event and tells me his party of 75 now wants more space, so he's kicking us out. So unprofessional. He should have simply said no to them, that the bar was full.